Day 25 — The Love Note by Joanna Davidson Politano

Daily Recommendation · No. 025

★★★★☆ 4/5 stars

Closed door / No spice | Christian romance

historical romanceepistolarymistaken identityfaith restorationforced proximity

A Victorian mystery wrapped inside a love story, The Love Note by Joanna Davidson Politano is the kind of book that sneaks up on you with its warmth and then refuses to let go.

Set in 1865 England, the story follows Willa Duvall, a young woman who discovers an unopened love letter hidden inside her old writing desk and becomes utterly consumed by one question: who was it meant for? Her search leads her to a nursing position at the grand and secretive Crestwicke Manor, where the household is full of complicated relationships, buried feelings, and a love story that has been waiting far too long to be told.

What genuinely surprised me here was the humour. This is a Victorian historical, so I went in expecting atmosphere and longing, and I got plenty of both, but Politano also delivers some genuinely funny comic chaos when the letter keeps getting misplaced and various members of the household find it and each assume it must be meant for them. The timing is perfect, and it gives the story a lightness that keeps it from ever feeling heavy-handed. But the comedy is never at the expense of the emotional core, and underneath all of it is something really tender about what love looked like before you could just send a quick message to someone. The weight a single letter once carried, the way words had to do absolutely all the work, is something this book captures beautifully.

Politano's prose is lyrical and atmospheric in all the right ways, pulling you fully into the Victorian setting without ever making it feel like a history lesson. The faith thread woven through the story is also worth mentioning because it earns its place, feeling genuinely moving rather than decorative or preachy. At four stars, this is a warm, lovely read and honestly a wonderful entry point into historical romance if it's a genre you haven't spent much time in yet.

Not a 5-star read for me, but a rating is just one reader's experience. If the tropes above are your thing, this could be exactly what you're looking for. I'd rather share it than gatekeep it.

Find it on Amazon →

This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my link, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you, it helps keep Trope and Tell going. Thank you.